Published on AgileConnection (https://www.agileconnection.com)

Home > Do agile assessment tools really serve any pupose in predicticting aglity?
shelly Bajwa's picture

Do agile assessment tools really serve any pupose in predicticting aglity?

shelly Bajwa asked on January 18, 2015 - 7:32am | Replies (2).

Can we really get good insight,  while  asking certain questions on agility, how it is practiced etc from agile team menmbers.

anthony joyce's picture

Johanna is spot on.  From a slightly different perspective in an organization that is not that consistent in conducting assessments and introspection, I find the purpose is not to predict velocity or even your work estimates or future plans.  Rather, the assessment should help you understand how much you know about your requirements, customers, legacy systems and future architecture.  If you continually find surpises at every turn, then perhaps you aren't as organized or connected as you "should be" and you are likely rushing towards a failed project.   

Johanna Rothman's picture

HI Shelly,

When I do agile assessments, it's not about predicting agility. I use assessments for understanding the current system. 

I often discover that teams and managers think they are doing some form of agile, and it's not. They do water-scrum-falls, or they have people in silo'd functions trying to work together. Or, they have managers plucking people from one project to another. There are plenty more problems. Those are three I have seen.

The assessment is about why things work or don't work. Assessments are not about predicting velocity, or if you can complete a project on time.

Assessments are useful for seeing the current system, and understanding the possibilities.

 

2 Answers

Johanna Rothman's picture

HI Shelly,

When I do agile assessments, it's not about predicting agility. I use assessments for understanding the current system. 

I often discover that teams and managers think they are doing some form of agile, and it's not. They do water-scrum-falls, or they have people in silo'd functions trying to work together. Or, they have managers plucking people from one project to another. There are plenty more problems. Those are three I have seen.

The assessment is about why things work or don't work. Assessments are not about predicting velocity, or if you can complete a project on time.

Assessments are useful for seeing the current system, and understanding the possibilities.

 

anthony joyce's picture

Johanna is spot on.  From a slightly different perspective in an organization that is not that consistent in conducting assessments and introspection, I find the purpose is not to predict velocity or even your work estimates or future plans.  Rather, the assessment should help you understand how much you know about your requirements, customers, legacy systems and future architecture.  If you continually find surpises at every turn, then perhaps you aren't as organized or connected as you "should be" and you are likely rushing towards a failed project.   
©2011-2013 TechWell Corp.